Phoenix unrest murder trial: Witness grilled for ‘inconsistent’ statements
Updated | By Gcinokuhle Malinga
The credibility of a state witness in the July unrest trial came under scrutiny at the Durban High Court on Wednesday.
Four men are on trial for the murder of Njabulo Dlamini, and the attempted murder of two others in Phoenix during the civil unrest in 2021.
It's alleged the victims had gone to buy illegally sold liquor at a tavern during the Covid-19 lockdown when they were attacked.
Defence attorney Wesley Rodgers grilled the State witness about inconsistencies in his police statements regarding the brutal assault that led to Dlamini’s death.
Rodgers, who represents accused numbers three and four, Tyreece and Timothy Govender, cross-examined the witness about the statements he gave concerning the roles the two men allegedly played in the attack, and about when he learned that Dlamini had died from his injuries.
The witness, who cannot be named, told the court that when he was first taken to the police station and questioned, he gave a brief version of events that played out at Tees Tavern, owned by his former employer, who is also on trial.
The witness said he only identified the attackers after police showed him videos of the victim being assaulted with sticks, but was unsure whether that detail was recorded in his first or second statement.
Rodgers challenged the timing, asking why the witness did not mention the two accused in his first statement if he had indeed witnessed the incident.
Judge Mluleki Chithi also questioned whether the witness had deliberately withheld information.
Rodgers revealed that Dlamini, who was known to the witness, died before the witness’s first police statement was made.
He further pressed the man in the stand on when exactly he knew that Dlamini had died and why he would give a statement in a murder case if he was unsure.
After the witness admitted that he assumed Dlamini had died based on rumours from locals, Rodgers argued that the witness was presenting assumptions rather than facts.
The defence lawyer concluded that the inconsistencies showed the witness’s evidence could not be trusted.
Find us on social media
Follow the ECR Newswatch WhatsApp channel here
We are also on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter)
MORE ON ECR
Show's Stories
-
The dark side of nursery rhymes
We grew up singing them, but what if our favourite nursery rhymes weren’t …
Stacey & J Sbu 13 hours ago -
Are you feeling that year end fatigue?
As the year ends and the festive season approaches, many of us hit a low e…
Danny Guselli 18 hours ago